Our Claim:
The transition from middle to high school significantly affects students’ phone use, shifting from restrictive policies to greater autonomy while enhancing social interactions. Still, it also negatively impacts the increase in procrastination, later sleep, and academic performance with instant gratification.
We choose to do a presentation around the middle to high school phone use transition. I think we did fine, we had a clear claim and evidence to support it. However, next time we should relate our topic more to things other than instant gratification since we had a lot of information on it.
What feedback we got:
- Good Q&A evidence is listed to support our focus on high schoolers.
“According to the EdWeek video, high schoolers have more liberty in device use than in middle school. This results in a more social community with no devices. The freedom to use phones also leads to procrastination, as students may prioritize social interactions over academic responsibilities during school time and be on devices after school. This shift can result in students delaying homework and study time.
The cumulative effects of increased phone use and procrastination have long-term consequences on academic performance. The video suggests that these factors can contribute to lower grades and diminished engagement in school activities over time which reflects our claim that sudden liberty gives instant gratification instead of a steady change in phone/device habits.”
- Improvement tip:
- There is a lot of instant gratification information, but not as much evidence/ information on other topics like schools’ names that have a no-phone policy in high school, what we should do, and what we are doing now.
My Feedback to myself:
I did lots of research on this unit. For areas that need to be improved, I would say to present better, with confidence and more reasoning/explanation of the evidence in my research document.
I recognize that the constant presence on screens and social media can be distracting, potentially affecting my focus and academic performance. After this unit, I have come up with a plan to practice self-management by setting specific boundaries for my phone use during school hours. For instance, I will keep my phone on silent and stored away during classes, and give my phone to my parents when doing homework. This action allows me to concentrate fully on my studies.
Additionally, I will designate specific times for checking messages or social media, ensuring that these activities don’t interfere with my learning. By being mindful of how I engage with my phone, I want to minimize the distractions caused by my phone and enhance my overall productivity in school.